2025 LCFS Pathways Requiring Public Comments
Contact
Instructions for Submitting Comments
For Temporary and Lookup Table Pathways:
- View the pathway documentation by selecting the pathway description.
- In the comment Subject line, include the pathway description. For example, "Comments for CA grid electricity used in Smart Charging or Smart Electrolysis".
For Tier 2 Pathways:
- View the application package by selecting the Application Number (i.e., "B0008").
- In the comment Subject line, please include the specific application number. For example, "Comments for application no. B0008".
For each posted item, comments are due at 5 PM PST on the deadline shown.
All comments received are posted in the Comments Log.
Proposed New Temporary Pathways (2025)
Pursuant to the LCFS regulation, the Executive Officer may approve a new Temporary pathway for a fuel or feedstock-fuel combination not found in the LCFS regulation. Public comments on proposed new Temporary fuel pathways (posted below) will be accepted for 45 days prior to certification. If relevant comments received during this period require significant revisions of the originally published pathway, an updated pathway will be posted for additional public comment. Upon certification, this new Temporary pathway will be available for LRT-CBTS reporting for the quarter in which it is certified.
| Posted Date | Temporary Pathway Description | Comment Deadline | Public Comments |
|---|---|---|---|
| TBD |
|
Proposed Annual Updates to Lookup Table Pathways (2025)
Section 95488.9(b)(4) of the LCFS regulation directs the Executive Officer to update the CI annually for the following Lookup Table pathways:
- California average grid electricity used as a transportation fuel in California
- Electricity supplied under the smart charging or smart electrolysis provision
Prior to certification, the updated pathway CI values will be posted for 45 days for public comment. The Executive Officer will review and respond to relevant comments received during this period. Once certified, the updated pathway CI values are expected to be available for quarterly fuel reporting in the first quarter (Q1) of the year.
| Posted Date | Lookup Table Pathway Description | Comment Deadline | Public Comments |
|---|---|---|---|
3/24/2025 | 2025 Update: California Average Grid Electricity Used as a Transportation Fuel in California and Electricity Supplied under the Smart Charging or Smart Electrolysis Provision | 5/8/2025 | Comment Period Closed No Comments Received |
Tier 2 Pathway Applications (2025)
Pursuant to the LCFS regulation, Tier 2 fuel pathway application packages are posted to this webpage for public comment after evaluation. Comments on each posted application package are accepted for ten (10) business days. Comments identifying potential factual or methodological errors in an application will be forwarded to the applicant. Upon receiving valid comments, applicants must either correct the errors identified and submit a revised application packet reflecting those corrections or submit a detailed written response to the Executive Officer explaining why no revisions are necessary.
Tier 2 pathways that do not receive any comments or those for which the applicant has provided responses deemed sufficient by the Executive Officer are certified and posted at Pathway Certified Carbon Intensities.
| Posted Date | Tier 2 Pathway Description | Comment Deadline | Comments and Responses |
|---|---|---|---|
| 9/12/2025 | PHILLIPS 66 COMPANY (4528); California B082501: Fuel Producer: PHILLIPS 66 COMPANY (4528); Facility Name: Phillips 66 Rodeo (82191); North American Soybean Oil transported by barge, ocean tanker and rail to Rodeo facility in California; natural gas, renewable off-gas, grid electricity and hydrogen; Renewable Diesel distributed in California via barge and pipeline [PROV3.0] B082502: Fuel Producer: PHILLIPS 66 COMPANY (4528); Facility Name: Phillips 66 Rodeo (82191); North American Soybean Oil transported by barge, ocean tanker and rail to Rodeo facility in California; natural gas, renewable off-gas, grid electricity and hydrogen; Alternative Jet Fuel distributed in California via barge and pipeline [PROV3.0] B082503: Fuel Producer: PHILLIPS 66 COMPANY (4528); Facility Name: Phillips 66 Rodeo (82191); North American Soybean Oil transported by barge, ocean tanker and rail to Rodeo facility in California; natural gas, renewable off-gas, grid electricity and hydrogen; Renewable Naphtha distributed in California via barge [PROV3.0] B082504: Fuel Producer: PHILLIPS 66 COMPANY (4528); Facility Name: Phillips 66 Rodeo (82191); North American Canola Oil transported by ocean tanker and rail to Rodeo facility in California; natural gas, renewable off-gas, grid electricity and hydrogen; Renewable Diesel distributed in California via barge and pipeline. [PROV3.0] B082505: Fuel Producer: PHILLIPS 66 COMPANY (4528); Facility Name: Phillips 66 Rodeo (82191); North American Canola Oil transported by ocean tanker and rail to Rodeo facility in California; natural gas, renewable off-gas, grid electricity and hydrogen; Alternative Jet Fuel distributed in California via barge and pipeline [PROV3.0] B082506: Fuel Producer: PHILLIPS 66 COMPANY (4528); Facility Name: Phillips 66 Rodeo (82191); North American Canola Oil transported by ocean tanker and rail to Rodeo facility in California; natural gas, renewable off-gas, grid electricity and hydrogen; Renewable Naphtha distributed in California via barge [PROV3.0] B082507: Fuel Producer: PHILLIPS 66 COMPANY (4528); Facility Name: Phillips 66 Rodeo (82191); US sourced Distiller’s Corn Oil transported by barge and rail to Rodeo facility in California; natural gas, renewable off-gas, grid electricity and hydrogen; Renewable Diesel distributed in California via barge and pipeline [PROV3.0] B082508: Fuel Producer: PHILLIPS 66 COMPANY (4528); Facility Name: Phillips 66 Rodeo (82191); US sourced Distiller’s Corn Oil transported by barge and rail to Rodeo facility in California; natural gas, renewable off-gas, grid electricity and hydrogen; Alternative Jet Fuel distributed in California barge and pipeline [PROV3.0] B082509: Fuel Producer: PHILLIPS 66 COMPANY (4528); Facility Name: Phillips 66 Rodeo (82191); US sourced Distiller’s Corn Oil transported by barge and rail to Rodeo facility in California; natural gas, renewable off-gas, grid electricity and hydrogen; Renewable Naphtha distributed in California via barge [PROV3.0] B082510: Fuel Producer: PHILLIPS 66 COMPANY (4528); Facility Name: Phillips 66 Rodeo (82191); Asian Used Cooking Oil transported by ocean tanker and truck to Rodeo facility in California; natural gas, renewable off-gas, grid electricity and hydrogen; Renewable Diesel distributed in California via barge and pipeline [PROV3.0] B082511: Fuel Producer: PHILLIPS 66 COMPANY (4528); Facility Name: Phillips 66 Rodeo (82191); Asian Used Cooking Oil transported by ocean tanker and truck to Rodeo facility in California; natural gas, renewable off-gas, grid electricity and hydrogen; Renewable Naphtha distributed in California via barge [PROV3.0] B082512: Fuel Producer: PHILLIPS 66 COMPANY (4528); Facility Name: Phillips 66 Rodeo (82191); Asian Used Cooking Oil transported by ocean tanker and truck to Rodeo facility in California; natural gas, renewable off-gas, grid electricity and hydrogen; Alternative Jet Fuel distributed in California via barge and pipeline [PROV3.0 B082513: Fuel Producer: PHILLIPS 66 COMPANY (4528); Facility Name: Phillips 66 Rodeo (82191); Used Cooking Oil from Malaysia/Indonesia transported by ocean tanker and truck to Rodeo facility in California; natural gas, renewable off-gas, grid electricity and hydrogen; Renewable Diesel distributed in California via barge and pipeline [PROV3.0] B082514: Fuel Producer: PHILLIPS 66 COMPANY (4528); Facility Name: Phillips 66 Rodeo (82191); Used Cooking Oil from Malaysia/Indonesia transported by ocean tanker and truck to Rodeo facility in California; natural gas, renewable off-gas, grid electricity and hydrogen; Alternative Jet Fuel distributed in California via barge and pipeline [PROV3.0] B082515: Fuel Producer: PHILLIPS 66 COMPANY (4528); Facility Name: Phillips 66 Rodeo (82191); Used Cooking Oil from Malaysia/Indonesia transported by ocean tanker and truck to Rodeo facility in California; natural gas, renewable off-gas, grid electricity and hydrogen; Renewable Naphtha distributed in California via barge [PROV3.0] B082516: Fuel Producer: PHILLIPS 66 COMPANY (4528); Facility Name: Phillips 66 Rodeo (82191); Used Cooking Oil from China transported by ocean tanker and truck to Rodeo facility in California; natural gas, renewable off-gas, grid electricity and hydrogen; Renewable Diesel distributed in California via barge and pipeline [PROV3.0] B082517: Fuel Producer: PHILLIPS 66 COMPANY (4528); Facility Name: Phillips 66 Rodeo (82191); Used Cooking Oil from China transported by ocean tanker and truck to Rodeo facility in California; natural gas, renewable off-gas, grid electricity and hydrogen; Alternative Jet Fuel distributed in California via barge and pipeline [PROV3.0] B082518: Fuel Producer: PHILLIPS 66 COMPANY (4528); Facility Name: Phillips 66 Rodeo (82191); Used Cooking Oil from China transported by ocean tanker and truck to Rodeo facility in California; natural gas, renewable off-gas, grid electricity and hydrogen; Renewable Naphtha distributed in California via barge [PROV3.0] B082519: Fuel Producer: PHILLIPS 66 COMPANY (4528); Facility Name: Phillips 66 Rodeo (82191); North American Tallow transported by rail to Rodeo facility in California; natural gas, renewable off-gas, grid electricity and hydrogen; Renewable Diesel distributed in California via barge and pipeline [PROV3.0] B082520: Fuel Producer: PHILLIPS 66 COMPANY (4528); Facility Name: Phillips 66 Rodeo (82191); North American Tallow transported by rail to Rodeo facility in California; natural gas, renewable off-gas, grid electricity and hydrogen; Alternative Jet Fuel distributed in California via barge and pipeline [PROV3.0] B082521: Fuel Producer: PHILLIPS 66 COMPANY (4528); Facility Name: Phillips 66 Rodeo (82191); North American Tallow transported by rail to Rodeo facility in California; natural gas, renewable off-gas, grid electricity and hydrogen; Renewable Naphtha distributed in California via barge [PROV3.0] B082522: Fuel Producer: PHILLIPS 66 COMPANY (4528); Facility Name: Phillips 66 Rodeo (82191); European Tallow transported by ocean tanker and truck to Rodeo facility in California; natural gas, renewable off-gas, grid electricity and hydrogen; Renewable Diesel distributed in California via barge and pipeline [PROV3.0] B082523: Fuel Producer: PHILLIPS 66 COMPANY (4528); Facility Name: Phillips 66 Rodeo (82191); European Tallow transported by ocean tanker and truck to Rodeo facility in California; natural gas, renewable off-gas, grid electricity and hydrogen; Alternative Jet Fuel distributed in California via barge and pipeline [PROV3.0] B082524: Fuel Producer: PHILLIPS 66 COMPANY (4528); Facility Name: Phillips 66 Rodeo (82191); European Tallow transported by ocean tanker and truck to Rodeo facility in California; natural gas, renewable off-gas, grid electricity and hydrogen; Renewable Naphtha distributed in California via barge [PROV3.0] B082525: Fuel Producer: PHILLIPS 66 COMPANY (4528); Facility Name: Phillips 66 Rodeo (82191); Tallow from Africa transported by ocean tanker and truck to Rodeo facility in California; natural gas, renewable off-gas, grid electricity and hydrogen; Renewable Diesel distributed in California via barge and pipeline [PROV3.0] B082526: Fuel Producer: PHILLIPS 66 COMPANY (4528); Facility Name: Phillips 66 Rodeo (82191); Tallow from Africa transported by ocean tanker and truck to Rodeo facility in California; natural gas, renewable off-gas, grid electricity and hydrogen; Alternative Jet Fuel distributed in California via barge and pipeline [PROV3.0] B082527: Fuel Producer: PHILLIPS 66 COMPANY (4528); Facility Name: Phillips 66 Rodeo (82191); Tallow from Africa transported by ocean tanker and truck to Rodeo facility in California; natural gas, renewable off-gas, grid electricity and hydrogen; Renewable Naphtha distributed in California via barge [PROV3.0] B082528: Fuel Producer: PHILLIPS 66 COMPANY (4528); Facility Name: Phillips 66 Rodeo (82191); Argentinian soybean oil transported by ocean tanker to Rodeo facility in California; natural gas, renewable off-gas, grid electricity and hydrogen; Renewable Diesel distributed in California via barge and pipeline [PROV3.0] B082529: Fuel Producer: PHILLIPS 66 COMPANY (4528); Facility Name: Phillips 66 Rodeo (82191); Argentinian soybean oil transported by ocean tanker to Rodeo facility in California; natural gas, renewable off-gas, grid electricity and hydrogen; Alternative Jet Fuel distributed in California via barge and pipeline [PROV3.0] B082530: Fuel Producer: PHILLIPS 66 COMPANY (4528); Facility Name: Phillips 66 Rodeo (82191); Argentinian soybean oil transported by ocean tanker to Rodeo facility in California; natural gas, renewable off-gas, grid electricity and hydrogen; Renewable Naphtha distributed in California via barge [PROV3.0] B082531: Fuel Producer: PHILLIPS 66 COMPANY (4528); Facility Name: Phillips 66 Rodeo (82191); North American Used Cooking Oil transported by rail to Rodeo facility in California; natural gas, renewable off-gas, grid electricity and hydrogen; Renewable Diesel distributed in California via barge and pipeline [PROV3.0] B082532: Fuel Producer: PHILLIPS 66 COMPANY (4528); Facility Name: Phillips 66 Rodeo (82191); North American Used Cooking Oil transported by rail to Rodeo facility in California; natural gas, renewable off-gas, grid electricity and hydrogen; Alternative Jet Fuel distributed in California via barge and pipeline [PROV3.0] B082533: Fuel Producer: PHILLIPS 66 COMPANY (4528); Facility Name: Phillips 66 Rodeo (82191); North American Used Cooking Oil transported by rail to Rodeo facility in California; natural gas, renewable off-gas, grid electricity and hydrogen; Renewable Naphtha distributed in California via barge [PROV3.0] B082534: Fuel Producer: PHILLIPS 66 COMPANY (4528); Facility Name: Phillips 66 Rodeo (82191); Asian Tallow transported by ocean tanker and truck to Rodeo facility in California; natural gas, renewable off-gas, grid electricity and hydrogen; Renewable Diesel distributed in California via barge and pipeline [PROV3.0] B082535: Fuel Producer: PHILLIPS 66 COMPANY (4528); Facility Name: Phillips 66 Rodeo (82191); Asian Tallow transported by ocean tanker and truck to Rodeo facility in California; natural gas, renewable off-gas, grid electricity and hydrogen; Alternative Jet Fuel distributed in California via barge and pipeline [PROV3.0] B082536: Fuel Producer: PHILLIPS 66 COMPANY (4528); Facility Name: Phillips 66 Rodeo (82191); Asian Tallow transported by ocean tanker and truck to Rodeo facility in California; natural gas, renewable off-gas, grid electricity and hydrogen; Renewable Naphtha distributed in California via barge [PROV3.0] B082537: Fuel Producer: PHILLIPS 66 COMPANY (4528); Facility Name: Phillips 66 Rodeo (82191); Tallow from Oceania transported by ocean tanker and truck to Rodeo facility in California; natural gas, renewable off-gas, grid electricity and hydrogen; Renewable Diesel distributed in California via barge and pipeline [PROV3.0] B082538: Fuel Producer: PHILLIPS 66 COMPANY (4528); Facility Name: Phillips 66 Rodeo (82191); Tallow from Oceania transported by ocean tanker and truck to Rodeo facility in California; natural gas, renewable off-gas, grid electricity and hydrogen; Alternative Jet Fuel distributed in California via barge and pipeline [PROV3.0] B082539: Fuel Producer: PHILLIPS 66 COMPANY (4528); Facility Name: Phillips 66 Rodeo (82191); Tallow from Oceania transported by ocean tanker and truck to Rodeo facility in California; natural gas, renewable off-gas, grid electricity and hydrogen; Renewable Naphtha distributed in California via barge [PROV3.0] B082540: Fuel Producer: PHILLIPS 66 COMPANY (4528); Facility Name: Phillips 66 Rodeo (82191); South American Tallow (excluding Brazil) transported by ocean tanker and truck to Rodeo facility in California; natural gas, renewable off-gas, grid electricity and hydrogen; Renewable Diesel distributed in California via barge and pipeline [PROV3.0] B082541: Fuel Producer: PHILLIPS 66 COMPANY (4528); Facility Name: Phillips 66 Rodeo (82191); South American Tallow (excluding Brazil) transported by ocean tanker and truck to Rodeo facility in California; natural gas, renewable off-gas, grid electricity and hydrogen; Alternative Jet Fuel distributed in California via barge and pipeline [PROV3.0] B082542: Fuel Producer: PHILLIPS 66 COMPANY (4528); Facility Name: Phillips 66 Rodeo (82191); South American Tallow (excluding Brazil) transported by ocean tanker and truck to Rodeo facility in California; natural gas, renewable off-gas, grid electricity and hydrogen; Renewable Naphtha distributed in California via barge [PROV3.0] B082543: Fuel Producer: PHILLIPS 66 COMPANY (4528); Facility Name: Phillips 66 Rodeo (82191); Brazilian Tallow transported by ocean tanker and truck to Rodeo facility in California; natural gas, renewable off-gas, grid electricity and hydrogen; Renewable Diesel distributed in California via barge and pipeline [PROV3.0] B082544: Fuel Producer: PHILLIPS 66 COMPANY (4528); Facility Name: Phillips 66 Rodeo (82191); Brazilian Tallow transported by ocean tanker and truck to Rodeo facility in California; natural gas, renewable off-gas, grid electricity and hydrogen; Alternative Jet Fuel distributed in California via barge and pipeline [PROV3.0] B082545: Fuel Producer: PHILLIPS 66 COMPANY (4528); Facility Name: Phillips 66 Rodeo (82191); Brazilian Tallow transported by ocean tanker and truck to Rodeo facility in California; natural gas, renewable off-gas, grid electricity and hydrogen; Renewable Naphtha distributed in California via barge [PROV3.0] B082546: Fuel Producer: PHILLIPS 66 COMPANY (4528); Facility Name: Phillips 66 Rodeo (82191); South American Used Cooking Oil transported by ocean tanker and truck to Rodeo facility in California; natural gas, renewable off-gas, grid electricity and hydrogen; Renewable Diesel distributed in California via barge and pipeline [PROV3.0] B082547: Fuel Producer: PHILLIPS 66 COMPANY (4528); Facility Name: Phillips 66 Rodeo (82191); South American Used Cooking Oil transported by ocean tanker and truck to Rodeo facility in California; natural gas, renewable off-gas, grid electricity and hydrogen; Alternative Jet Fuel distributed in California via barge and pipeline [PROV3.0] B082548: Fuel Producer: PHILLIPS 66 COMPANY (4528); Facility Name: Phillips 66 Rodeo (82191); South American Used Cooking Oil transported by ocean tanker and truck to Rodeo facility in California; natural gas, renewable off-gas, grid electricity and hydrogen; Renewable Naphtha distributed in California via barge [PROV3.0] B082549: Fuel Producer: PHILLIPS 66 COMPANY (4528); Facility Name: Phillips 66 Rodeo (82191); Used Cooking Oil from Oceania transported by ocean tanker and truck to Rodeo facility in California; natural gas, renewable off-gas, grid electricity and hydrogen; Renewable Diesel distributed in California via barge and pipeline [PROV3.0] B082550: Fuel Producer: PHILLIPS 66 COMPANY (4528); Facility Name: Phillips 66 Rodeo (82191); Used Cooking Oil from Oceania transported by ocean tanker and truck to Rodeo facility in California; natural gas, renewable off-gas, grid electricity and hydrogen; Alternative Jet Fuel distributed in California via barge and pipeline [PROV3.0] B082551: Fuel Producer: PHILLIPS 66 COMPANY (4528); Facility Name: Phillips 66 Rodeo (82191); Used Cooking Oil from Oceania transported by ocean tanker and truck to Rodeo facility in California; natural gas, renewable off-gas, grid electricity and hydrogen; Renewable Naphtha distributed in California via barge [PROV3.0] | 9/26/2025 | Submit Comments |
| 9/11/2025 | Chevron RNG Holdings LLC (C1197); Michigan B082401: Fuel Producer: Chevron RNG Holdings LLC (C1197); Facility Name: Chevron Willow Point RNG LLC (F00644); Biogas from dairy manure at Willow Point Dairy, LLC in Orleans, MI; upgraded to pipeline quality at Chevron Willow Point RNG LLC; trucked to pipeline injection site and pipelined to California for transportation use [PROV3.0] | 9/25/2025 | Submit Comments |
| 9/11/2025 | DENCO II, LLC. (3818); Minnesota B089101: Fuel Producer: DENCO II, LLC. (3818); Facility Name: DENCO II, LLC (70082); Midwest Corn, Dry Mill, Dry DGS, Distillers Corn Oil; Ethanol produced from Corn Starch using Natural Gas, Propane, Grid Electricity; Ethanol produced in Morris, Minnesota is transported by Rail to California. [PROV3.0] B089102: Fuel Producer: DENCO II, LLC. (3818); Facility Name: DENCO II, LLC (70082); Midwest Corn, Dry Mill, Wet DGS, Distillers Corn Oil; Ethanol produced from Corn Starch using Natural Gas, Propane, Grid Electricity; Ethanol produced in Morris, Minnesota is transported by Rail to California. [PROV3.0] B089103: Fuel Producer: DENCO II, LLC. (3818); Facility Name: DENCO II, LLC (70082); Midwest Corn, Dry Mill; Cellulosic Ethanol derived from Corn Fiber using the Soliton conversion process; Natural Gas, Propane, Grid Electricity, Cellulosic Ethanol produced in Morris, Minnesota; Ethanol transported by Rail to California. [PROV3.0] | 9/25/2025 | Submit Comments |
| 9/11/2025 | ST BERNARD RENEWABLES LLC (1974); Louisiana B077401: Fuel Producer: ST BERNARD RENEWABLES LLC (1974); Facility Name: St Bernard Renewables LLC (82901); South East Asian sourced UCO transported by truck, ocean vessel, and barge to Renewable Diesel plant in Chalmette, LA; Natural Gas, Hydrogen, Electricity; finished fuel transported to California via ocean tanker. [PROV3.0] B077402: Fuel Producer: ST BERNARD RENEWABLES LLC (1974); Facility Name: St Bernard Renewables LLC (82901); Central American sourced used cooking oil transported by truck, ocean vessel, and barge to Renewable Diesel plant in Chalmette, LA; Natural Gas, Hydrogen, Electricity; finished fuel transported to California via ocean tanker. [PROV3.0] B077403: Fuel Producer: ST BERNARD RENEWABLES LLC (1974); Facility Name: St Bernard Renewables LLC (82901); Puerto Rican / Cayman Islands sourced used cooking oil transported by truck, ocean vessel, and rail to Renewable Diesel plant in Chalmette, LA; Natural Gas, Hydrogen, Electricity; finished fuel transported to California via ocean tanker. [PROV3.0] B077404: Fuel Producer: ST BERNARD RENEWABLES LLC (1974); Facility Name: St Bernard Renewables LLC (82901); Australian/New Zealand sourced animal fat transported by truck, ocean vessel, and barge to Renewable Diesel plant in Chalmette, LA; Natural Gas, Hydrogen, Electricity; finished fuel transported to California via ocean tanker. [PROV3.0] B077405: Fuel Producer: ST BERNARD RENEWABLES LLC (1974); Facility Name: St Bernard Renewables LLC (82901); Mexican sourced animal fat transported by truck and rail to Renewable Diesel plant in Chalmette, LA; Natural Gas, Hydrogen, Electricity; finished fuel transported to California via ocean tanker. [PROV3.0] B077406: Fuel Producer: ST BERNARD RENEWABLES LLC (1974); Facility Name: St Bernard Renewables LLC (82901); United Kingdom sourced animal fat transported by truck, and ocean vessel to Renewable Diesel plant in Chalmette, LA; Natural Gas, Hydrogen, Electricity; finished fuel transported to California via ocean tanker. [PROV3.0] | 9/25/2025 | Submit Comments |
| 9/10/2025 | MONTANA RENEWABLES, LLC (1876); Montana B078701: Fuel Producer: MONTANA RENEWABLES, LLC (1876); Facility Name: MRL Great Falls (F00548); U.S. sourced Used Cooking Oil (UCO) collected and transported by rail to Renewable Diesel plant in Great Falls, Montana; NG, Electricity; finished renewable diesel fuel transported to California by truck and rail. [3.0] B078702: Fuel Producer: MONTANA RENEWABLES, LLC (1876); Facility Name: MRL Great Falls (F00548); U.S. sourced Used Cooking Oil (UCO) collected and transported by rail to Renewable Diesel plant in Great Falls, Montana; NG, Electricity; finished Alterative Jet Fuel transported to California by truck and rail. [3.0] B078703: Fuel Producer: MONTANA RENEWABLES, LLC (1876); Facility Name: MRL Great Falls (F00548); U.S. sourced Used Cooking Oil (UCO) collected and transported by rail to Renewable Diesel plant in Great Falls, Montana; NG, Electricity; finished Renewable Naphtha Fuel transported to California by truck and rail. [3.0] | 9/24/2025 | Comments Received: |
| 9/9/2025 | CVR RENEWABLES WYN, LLC (2120); Oklahoma B078401: Fuel Producer: CVR RENEWABLES WYN, LLC (2120); Facility Name: CVR RENEWABLES WYN, LLC (83001); US Sourced Soybean Oil transported by rail to Renewable Diesel plant in Wynnewood, OK; Natural Gas,Grid Electricity, and Hydrogen; finished fuel transported to California by rail. [PROV3.0] B078402: Fuel Producer: CVR RENEWABLES WYN, LLC (2120); Facility Name: CVR RENEWABLES WYN, LLC (83001); US Sourced Rendered Animal Fat transported by truck to Renewable Diesel plant in Wynnewood, OK; Natural Gas, Grid Electricity, and Hydrogen ; finished fuel transported to California by rail [PROV3.0] B078403: Fuel Producer: CVR RENEWABLES WYN, LLC (2120); Facility Name: CVR RENEWABLES WYN, LLC (83001); US Sourced Used Cooking Oil (UCO) transported by truck to Renewable Diesel plant in Wynnewood, OK; Natural Gas, Grid Electricity, and Hydrogen ; finished fuel transported to California by rail [PROV3.0] B078404: Fuel Producer: CVR RENEWABLES WYN, LLC (2120); Facility Name: CVR RENEWABLES WYN, LLC (83001); US Sourced Distillers' Corn Oil transported by truck and rail to Renewable Diesel plant in Wynnewood, OK; Natural Gas, Grid Electricity, and Hydrogen; finished fuel transported to California by rail [PROV3.0] B078405: Fuel Producer: CVR RENEWABLES WYN, LLC (2120); Facility Name: CVR RENEWABLES WYN, LLC (83001); US Sourced Pre-treated Distillers' Corn Oil transported by rail to Renewable Diesel plant in Wynnewood, OK; Natural Gas, Grid Electricity, and Hydrogen; finished fuel transported to California by rail [PROV3.0] | 9/23/2025 | Submit Comments |
| 9/5/2025 | LF Bioenergy LLC (C1241); New York B081001: Fuel Producer: LF Bioenergy LLC (C1241) ; Facility Name: LF Bioenergy LF1, LLC (F00657); Biogas from dairy manure at Stauffer Farms LLC in North Lawrence, NY and Forest View Heifers LLC in Nicholville, NY; upgraded to pipeline quality at LF Bioenergy LF1, LLC; pipelined to CA for transportation use [PROV3.0] | 9/19/2025 | Submit Comments |
| 8/26/2025 | TIDEWATER RENEWABLES LTD. (2045); Canada B076101: Fuel Producer: TIDEWATER RENEWABLES LTD. (2045); Facility Name: PRINCE GEORGE RENEWABLE DIESEL (84081); Canadian Sourced Canola Oil transported by rail to Renewable Diesel plant in British Columbia, Canada; Natural Gas and Grid Electricity; finished fuel transported to California by rail [PROV3.0] B076102: Fuel Producer: TIDEWATER RENEWABLES LTD. (2045); Facility Name: PRINCE GEORGE RENEWABLE DIESEL (84081); US-sourced Distillers' Corn Oil transported by rail to Renewable Diesel plant in British Columbia, Canada; Natural Gas and Grid Electricity; finished fuel transported to California by rail [PROV3.0] B076103: Fuel Producer: TIDEWATER RENEWABLES LTD. (2045); Facility Name: PRINCE GEORGE RENEWABLE DIESEL (84081); Canadian-sourced Animal Fat transported by truck and rail to Renewable Diesel plant in British Columbia, Canada; Natural Gas and Grid Electricity; finished fuel transported to California by rail [PROV3.0] B076104: Fuel Producer: TIDEWATER RENEWABLES LTD. (2045); Facility Name: PRINCE GEORGE RENEWABLE DIESEL (84081); Canadian-sourced Used Cooking Oil (UCO) transported by truck and rail to Renewable Diesel plant in British Columbia, Canada; Natural Gas and Grid Electricity; finished fuel transported to California by rail [PROV3.0] | 9/9/2025 | Comment Period Closed No Comments Received |
| 8/18/2025 | Loci Controls Inc (C1207); California B072401: Fuel Producer: Loci Controls Inc (C1207); Facility Name: Yolo County Central Landfill (F00717); Low-CI electricity generated from Landfill Gas using reciprocating engines at Yolo County Central Landfill in Woodland, California; Electricity used as transportation fuel in California [PROV3.0] | 9/2/2025 | Comment Period Closed No Comments Received |
| 6/12/2025 | Anew RNG, LLC (5877); Indiana B073001: Fuel Producer: Anew RNG, LLC (5877); Facility Name: RDB Environmental, LLC (F00556); Biogas from dairy manure at Hidden View Dairy LLC. in Rensselaer, IN; upgraded to pipeline quality at RDB Environmental, LLC; pipelined to CA for transportation use (PROV3.0) B073002: Fuel Producer: Anew RNG, LLC (5877); Facility Name: RDB Environmental, LLC (F00556); Biogas from dairy manure at De Jong Family Farm in Francesville, IN; upgraded to pipeline quality at RDB Environmental, LLC; pipelined to CA for transportation use (PROV3.0) | 6/26/2025 | Comment Period Closed Comments Received: Response to Comments |
| 6/11/2025 | Iwatani Corporation of America (C1024); California B074101: Fuel Producer: Iwatani Corporation of America (C1024); Facility Name: Linde-Praxair (F00088); Liquefied Hydrogen produced at Linde-Praxair hydrogen plant in Ontario, CA using Biomethane derived from landfill gas generated at Meadow Branch Landfill in Athens, TN; finished liquefied hydrogen fuel is transported in tanker trailers and re-gasified, recompressed at refueling stations in California. (3.0) B074102: Fuel Producer: Iwatani Corporation of America (C1024); Facility Name: Linde-Praxair (F00088); Gaseous Hydrogen produced at Linde-Praxair hydrogen plant in Ontario, CA using Biomethane derived from landfill gas generated at Meadow Branch Landfill in Athens, TN; finished gaseous hydrogen fuel is transported in tube trailers to refueling stations in California. (3.0) | 6/25/2025 | Comment Period Closed No Comments Received |
| 6/11/2025 | Cheyenne Renewable Diesel Company LLC (1647); Wyoming B074101: Fuel Producer: Cheyenne Renewable Diesel Company LLC (1647); Facility Name: Cheyenne Renewable Diesel Company LLC (F00494); Distillers Corn Oil transported by rail and truck to Renewable Diesel plant in Cheyenne, Wyoming; NG, Electricity; finished Renewable Diesel fuel shipped to California by rail. (3.0) B074102: Fuel Producer: Cheyenne Renewable Diesel Company LLC (1647); Facility Name: Cheyenne Renewable Diesel Company LLC (F00494); North American Canola Oil pretreated in Artesia, New Mexico; shipped to Renewable Diesel plant in Cheyenne, Wyoming by rail; NG, Electricity; finished Renewable Diesel shipped to California by rail. (3.0) | 6/25/2025 | Comment Period Closed No Comments Received |
| 6/10/2025 | Seaboard Energy, LLC (formerly known as High Plains Bioenergy) (4846); Kansas B074101: Fuel Producer: Seaboard Energy, LLC (formerly known as High Plains Bioenergy) (4846); Facility Name: SEABOARD ENERGY KANSAS, LLC (72061); U.S. sourced Distillers’ Corn Oil transported by rail and truck to Renewable Diesel plant in Hugoton, Kansas; NG, Electricity; Renewable Diesel fuel transported to California by rail. (PROV3.0) B074102: Fuel Producer: Seaboard Energy, LLC (formerly known as High Plains Bioenergy) (4846); Facility Name: SEABOARD ENERGY KANSAS, LLC (72061); U.S.-sourced Tallow Oil transported by Rail and Truck to Renewable Diesel plant in Hugoton, Kansas; NG, Electricity; Renewable Diesel fuel transported to California by Rail. (PROV3.0) B074103: Fuel Producer: Seaboard Energy, LLC (formerly known as High Plains Bioenergy) (4846); Facility Name: SEABOARD ENERGY KANSAS, LLC (72061); U.S. sourced Distillers’ Corn Oil transported by rail and truck to Renewable Diesel plant in Hugoton, Kansas; NG, Electricity; Renewable Naphtha fuel transported to California by rail. (PROV3.0) B074104: Fuel Producer: Seaboard Energy, LLC (formerly known as High Plains Bioenergy) (4846); Facility Name: SEABOARD ENERGY KANSAS, LLC (72061); U.S. sourced Tallow Oil transported by rail and truck to Renewable Diesel plant in Hugoton, Kansas; NG, Electricity; Renewable Naphtha fuel transported to California by rail. (PROV3.0) | 6/24/2025 | Comment Period Closed No Comments Received |
| 6/10/2025 | California Bioenergy LLC (B194); California B075201: Fuel Producer: California Bioenergy LLC (B194); Facility Name: ABEC Bidart-Stockdale LLC (F00114); Low-CI Electricity from Dairy Manure Biogas using reciprocating IC engine at ABEC Bidart-Stockdale LLC in Bakersfield, California for use as transportation fuel in California (PROV3.0) | 6/24/2025 | Comment Period Closed Comments Received: Response to Comments |
| 6/9/2025 | ARTESIA RENEWABLE DIESEL COMPANY LLC (1646); New Mexico B086101: Fuel Producer: ARTESIA RENEWABLE DIESEL COMPANY LLC (1646); Facility Name: RENEWABLE DIESEL UNIT (RDU) / PRE-TREATMENT UNIT (PTU) (82381); U.S.-sourced Used Cooking Oil collected and transported by rail and truck to Renewable Diesel plant in Artesia, New Mexico; NG, Electricity, finished fuel transported by rail to California. (3.0) | 6/23/2025 | Comment Period Closed No Comments Received |
| 6/2/2025 | Aemetis Advanced Fuels Keyes, Inc. (3566); California B075901: Fuel Producer: Aemetis Advanced Fuels Keyes, Inc. (3566); Facility Name: Aemetis Biogas LLC (F00629); Biogas from dairy manure at Double D Dairy in Ceres, CA; upgraded to pipeline quality at Aemetis Biogas LLC; pipelined to CA for transportation use (PROV3.0) B075902: Fuel Producer: Aemetis Advanced Fuels Keyes, Inc. (3566); Facility Name: Aemetis Biogas LLC (F00629); Biogas from dairy manure at Paul Ackerman Dairy in Ceres, CA; upgraded to pipeline quality at Aemetis Biogas LLC; pipelined to CA for transportation use (PROV3.0) B075903: Fuel Producer: Aemetis Advanced Fuels Keyes, Inc. (3566); Facility Name: Aemetis Biogas LLC (F00629); Biogas from dairy manure at AHLEM FARMS JERSEY in Crows Landing, CA; upgraded to pipeline quality at Aemetis Biogas LLC; pipelined to CA for transportation use (PROV3.0) B075904: Fuel Producer: Aemetis Advanced Fuels Keyes, Inc. (3566); Facility Name: Aemetis Biogas LLC (F00629); Biogas from dairy manure at Pinnacle Dairy LP in Crows Landing, CA; upgraded to pipeline quality at Aemetis Biogas LLC; pipelined to CA for transportation use (PROV3.0) B075905: Fuel Producer: Aemetis Advanced Fuels Keyes, Inc. (3566); Facility Name: Aemetis Biogas LLC (F00629); Biogas from dairy manure at S & S Dairy in Ceres, CA; upgraded to pipeline quality at Aemetis Biogas LLC; pipelined to CA for transportation use (PROV3.0) B075906: Fuel Producer: Aemetis Advanced Fuels Keyes, Inc. (3566); Facility Name: Aemetis Biogas LLC (F00629); Biogas from dairy manure at Trinkler Dairy in Ceres, CA; upgraded to pipeline quality at Aemetis Biogas LLC; pipelined to CA for transportation use (PROV3.0) B075907: Fuel Producer: Aemetis Advanced Fuels Keyes, Inc. (3566); Facility Name: Aemetis Biogas LLC (F00629); Biogas from dairy manure at Mendes Dairy and AM3 Dairy in Crows Landing, CA; upgraded to pipeline quality at Aemetis Biogas LLC; pipelined to CA for transportation use (PROV3.0) | 6/16/2025 | Comment Period Closed Comments Received: Response to Comments |
| 3/12/2025 | Lakeside Pipeline, LLC (C1158); California B072701: Fuel Producer: Lakeside Pipeline, LLC (C1158); Facility Name: Lakeside Pipeline, LLC (F00480); Biogas from dairy manure at Lakeside Energy Dairy Digester in Hanford, CA; upgraded to pipeline quality at Lakeside Pipeline, LLC; pipelined to CA for transportation use (PROV3.0) B072702: Fuel Producer: Lakeside Pipeline, LLC (C1158); Facility Name: Lakeside Pipeline, LLC (F00480); Biogas from dairy manure at Yokum Dairy Digester in Hanford, CA; upgraded to pipeline quality at Lakeside Pipeline, LLC; pipelined to CA for transportation use (PROV3.0) B072703: Fuel Producer: Lakeside Pipeline, LLC (C1158); Facility Name: Lakeside Pipeline, LLC (F00480); Biogas from dairy manure at Poplar Lane Dairy in Hanford, CA; upgraded to pipeline quality at Lakeside Pipeline, LLC; pipelined to CA for transportation use (PROV3.0) B072704: Fuel Producer: Lakeside Pipeline, LLC (C1158); Facility Name: Lakeside Pipeline, LLC (F00480); Biogas from dairy manure at High Roller Dairy in Hanford, CA; upgraded to pipeline quality at Lakeside Pipeline, LLC; pipelined to CA for transportation use (PROV3.0) | 3/26/2025 | Comment Period Closed Comments Received:
Response to Comments |
| 3/12/2025 | FIVE POINTS PIPELINE LLC (1763); California B068801: Fuel Producer: FIVE POINTS PIPELINE LLC (1763); Facility Name: FIVE POINTS PIPELINE LLC (82281); Biogas from dairy manure at Open Sky Power, LLC in Riverdale, CA; upgraded to pipeline quality at FIVE POINTS PIPELINE LLC; pipelined to CA for transportation use (PROV3.0) B068802: Fuel Producer: FIVE POINTS PIPELINE LLC (1763); Facility Name: FIVE POINTS PIPELINE LLC (82281); Biogas from dairy manure at Wilson Dairy Biogas, LLC in Riverdale, CA; upgraded to pipeline quality at FIVE POINTS PIPELINE LLC; pipelined to CA for transportation use (PROV3.0) B068803: Fuel Producer: FIVE POINTS PIPELINE LLC (1763); Facility Name: FIVE POINTS PIPELINE LLC (82281); Biogas from dairy manure at Van der Hoek Dairy Biogas, LLC in Helm CA; upgraded to pipeline quality at FIVE POINTS PIPELINE LLC; pipelined to CA for transportation use (PROV3.0) B068804: Fuel Producer: FIVE POINTS PIPELINE LLC (1763); Facility Name: FIVE POINTS PIPELINE LLC (82281); Biogas from dairy manure at L&J Vanderham Energy, LLC in Riverdale, CA; upgraded to pipeline quality at FIVE POINTS PIPELINE LLC; pipelined to CA for transportation use (PROV3.0) B068805: Fuel Producer: FIVE POINTS PIPELINE LLC (1763); Facility Name: FIVE POINTS PIPELINE LLC (82281); Biogas from dairy manure at Van der Kooi Dairy Power LLC in Riverdale, CA; upgraded to pipeline quality at FIVE POINTS PIPELINE LLC; pipelined to CA for transportation use (PROV3.0) | 3/26/2025 | Comment Period Closed Comments Received: Response to Comments |
| 3/10/2025 | WOF SW GGP 1 LLC (W009); Arizona B069801: Fuel Producer: WOF SW GGP 1 LLC (W009); Facility Name: Green Gas Partners Stanfield (F00003); Biogas from dairy manure at Shamrock Farms Dairy, Zinke Dairy, Inc., D&I Holstein, LLC, Feenstra Friesians in Stanfield, AZ, T&K Red River Dairy in Maricopa, AZ, Dickman & Sons Dairy LLC in Coolidge, AZ, and Arizona Dairy Co. LLP in Gila Bend, AZ; upgraded to pipeline quality at Green Gas Partners Stanfield; pipelined to CA for transportation use (PROV3.0) | 3/24/2025 | Comment Period Closed Comments Received: Response to Comments |
| 3/10/2025 | Braya Renewable Fuels (Newfoundland) LP (C1221); Canada B070301: Fuel Producer: Braya Renewable Fuels (Newfoundland) LP (C1221); Facility Name: Come By Chance Refinery (F00558); Argentina sourced Soybean Oil transported by ocean tanker, rail, truck to Renewable Diesel plant in Newfoundland and Labrador, Canada; Butane and Grid Electricity; transported to California by ocean tanker and truck (PROV3.0) B070302: Fuel Producer: Braya Renewable Fuels (Newfoundland) LP (C1221); Facility Name: Come By Chance Refinery (F00558); North American sourced Tallow transported by ocean tanker and rail to Renewable Diesel plant in Newfoundland and Labrador, Canada; Butane and Grid Electricity; transported to California by ocean tanker and truck (PROV3.0) B070303: Fuel Producer: Braya Renewable Fuels (Newfoundland) LP (C1221); Facility Name: Come By Chance Refinery (F00558); North American sourced Distiller’s Corn Oil transported by rail and truck to Renewable Diesel plant in Newfoundland and Labrador, Canada; Butane and Grid Electricity; transported to California by ocean tanker and truck (PROV3.0) | 3/24/2025 | Comment Period Closed Comments Received: 1. Rich Field Response to Comments |
| 3/10/2025 | BE8 S.A. (1829); Brazil B070701: Fuel Producer: BE8 S.A. (1829); Facility Name: BE8 S.A. (82361); Brazilian Tallow transported by rail/truck to Biodiesel plant in Passo Fundo, Rio Grande do Sul, Brazil; Biomass, Electricity; Biodiesel transported to California by Ocean Tanker (PROV3.0) | 3/24/2025 | Comment Period Closed No Comments Received |
| 3/7/2025 | Anew RNG, LLC (5877); North Carolina B077101: Fuel Producer: Anew RNG, LLC (5877); Facility Name: Grady Swine Facility (F00630); Biogas from swine manure at Kilpatrick Farm, Goodson Farm, M&M-Waters Farm, Dell Farm, DM Section 2, and DM Farm Section 3 in NC; upgraded to pipeline quality at Grady Swine Facility; pipelined to California for transportation use (PROV3.0) | 3/21/2025 | Comment Period Closed Comments Received: Response to Comments |
| 3/7/2025 | NLC Energy LLC (6496); Wisconsin B072201: Fuel Producer: NLC Energy LLC (6496); Facility Name: NLC Energy Denmark LLC (70242); Biogas from dairy manure at Rolling Hills Dairy, LLC, Leiterman Dairy, Barta Farm, LLC, Heim’s Hillcrest Dairy, LLC, Branch View Dairy Farm, D&D Dairy, Habeck Homestead Farms, LLC, Kostechka Dairy LLC, Neighborhood Dairy, United Vision Dairy LLC, The Buresh Farms LLC, in WI; upgraded to pipeline quality at NLC Energy Denmark LLC; pipelined to CA for transportation use (PROV3.0) | 3/21/2025 | Comment Period Closed Comments Received: Response to Comments |
| 3/4/2025 | GHI Energy, LLC (6156); New York B069201: Fuel Producer: GHI Energy, LLC (6156) ; Facility Name: Spruce Haven Dairy (F00568); Biogas from dairy manure at Spruce Haven Dairy in Union Springs, NY; upgraded to pipeline quality at Spruce Haven Dairy; pipelined to CA for transportation use (PROV3.0) | 3/18/2025 | Comment Period Closed Comments Received: Response to Comments |
| 3/4/2025 | GEVO NW IOWA RNG, LLC (1907); South Dakota B072501: Fuel Producer: GEVO NW IOWA RNG, LLC (1907) ; Facility Name: Gevo NW Iowa RNG, LLC (72561); Biogas from dairy manure at Meadowvale Dairy, LLC in Rock Valley, IA; upgraded to pipeline quality at Gevo NW Iowa RNG, LLC; pipelined to CA for transportation use (PROV3.0) B072502: Fuel Producer: GEVO NW IOWA RNG, LLC (1907); Facility Name: Gevo NW Iowa RNG, LLC (72561); Biogas from dairy manure at Rock River Jerseys, LLC in Inwood, IA; upgraded to pipeline quality at Gevo NW Iowa RNG, LLC; pipelined to CA for transportation use (PROV3.0) B072503: Fuel Producer: GEVO NW IOWA RNG, LLC (1907); Facility Name: Gevo NW Iowa RNG, LLC (72561); Biogas from dairy manure at Winding Meadows Dairy, Inc. in Rock Valley, IA; upgraded to pipeline quality at Gevo NW Iowa RNG, LLC; pipelined to CA for transportation use (PROV3.0) | 3/18/2025 | Comment Period Closed Comments Received: Response to Comments |
| 2/28/2025 | Messer LLC (f.k.a. Linde LLC) (L012); Nevada B077201: Fuel Producer: Messer LLC (f.k.a. Linde LLC) (L012); Facility Name: North Las Vegas Liquid Hydrogen Plant AL (F00640); Liquefied Hydrogen produced at the AL North Las Vegas Hydrogen Plant in Las Vegas, NV using biomethane derived from landfill gas generated at the Live Oak Landfill in Conley, GA; finished Liquefied Hydrogen fuel is transported in tanker trailers, re-gasified and compressed at the refueling station in California. (3.0) | 3/14/2025 | Comment Period Closed No Comments Received |
| 2/19/2025 | Messer LLC (f.k.a. Linde LLC) (L012); California B067901: Fuel Producer: Messer LLC (f.k.a. Linde LLC) (L012); Facility Name: Linde Praxair (F00477); Liquefied Hydrogen produced at Linde Praxair hydrogen plant in Ontario, CA using biomethane derived from landfill gas generated at the Live Oak Landfill in Conley, GA; Liquefied Hydrogen is transported in tanker trailers to refueling station in California (3.0) | 3/5/2025 | Comment Period Closed Comments Received: Response to Comments 1. Response Not Required |
| 2/6/2025 | Anew RNG, LLC (5877); Texas B068101: Fuel Producer: Anew RNG, LLC (5877); Facility Name: Perryton Biogas (F00639); Biogas from swine manure at Perryton Farm in Perryton, TX; upgraded to pipeline quality at Perryton Biogas; pipelined to CA for transportation use (PROV3.0) | 2/21/2025 | Comment Period Closed Comments Received: Response to Comments 1. Anew RNG, LLC responses to Mark Weinberger |
| 12/30/2024 | FirstElement Fuel (E426); Nevada B069501: Fuel Producer: FirstElement Fuel (E426); Facility Name: AL North Las Vegas Liquid Hydrogen Plant (F00523); Liquefied Hydrogen produced at Air Liquide N Las Vegas Hydrogen Plant using fossil Natural Gas; transported to trans-fill station in Etiwanda, California; re-gasified and compressed; gaseous hydrogen transported to refueling stations in California. (3.0) B069502: Fuel Producer: FirstElement Fuel (E426); Facility Name: AL North Las Vegas Liquid Hydrogen Plant (F00523); Liquefied Hydrogen produced at Air Liquide N Las Vegas Hydrogen Plant using biomethane procured from Yellow Jacket Lamb RNG Project; re-gasified and compressed at the trans-fill station in Etiwanda, CA; gaseous hydrogen transported to refueling stations. (3.0) B069503: Fuel Producer: FirstElement Fuel (E426); Facility Name: AL North Las Vegas Liquid Hydrogen Plant (F00523); Liquefied Hydrogen produced at Air Liquide N Las Vegas Hydrogen Plant using biomethane procured from Yellow Jacket Lakeshore RNG Project; re-gasified and compressed at trans-fill facility in Etiwanda, CA; gaseous hydrogen transported to refueling stations (3.0) B069504: Fuel Producer: FirstElement Fuel (E426); Facility Name: AL North Las Vegas Liquid Hydrogen Plant (F00523); Liquefied Hydrogen produced at Air Liquide N Las Vegas Hydrogen Plant using biomethane procured from Yellow Jacket Boxler RNG Project; re-gasified and compressed at trans-fill facility in Etiwanda; CA; gaseous hydrogen transported to refueling stations. (3.0) | 1/14/2025 | Comment Period Closed Comments Received: Response to Comments |