Draft Civil Rights Policy
Contact
Contacts
Contact the California Air Resources Board’s (CARB) Civil Rights Officer at [email protected] for questions about this Civil Rights Policy (Policy) or complaints of violations of this Policy.
Contact a CARB program or activity contact for questions about that program or activity that is not related to the Civil Rights Policy.
Policy Statement
It is CARB policy to provide fair and equal access to the benefits of a program or activity administered by CARB. CARB will not tolerate discrimination based on a protected class against any person seeking to participate in, or receive the benefits of, any program or activity offered or conducted by CARB. Members of the public who believe they were unlawfully denied full and equal access to a CARB program or activity based on a protected class may file a civil rights complaint with CARB under this Policy. Complaints regarding contractors, subcontractors, grantees, subgrantees, recipients, and vendors that CARB utilizes to provide benefits and services to members of the public may also be filed under this Civil Rights Policy. CARB may implement lawful programs or activities to address any past discrimination caused by a CARB program or activity, consistent with state and federal law.
Policy Violations
A violation of this Policy exists if evidence shows that it is more likely than not that a CARB program or activity engaged in discrimination based on a protected class against any person seeking to participate in, or receive the benefits of, any program or activity offered or conducted by CARB, or a CARB contractor, subcontractor, grantee, subgrantee, recipient, and vendor, as further described in this Policy.
Purpose
The purpose of the Civil Rights Policy is to:
- Confirm CARB’s Civil Rights Policy applies to its programs and activities.
- Describe the process to make a complaint to CARB alleging a Policy violation.
- Describe the process CARB’s Civil Rights Office will use to review and potentially investigate complaints in the jurisdiction of this Policy.
Jurisdiction
The Civil Rights Policy applies to actions taken to implement programs and activities by CARB, and its contractors, subcontractors, grantees, subgrantees, recipients, and vendors.
If a complaint to the Civil Rights Office is a personnel matter more appropriately addressed under the Equal Employment Opportunity (EEO) Policy, the Civil Rights Officer will notify the complainant and take appropriate next steps under that (EEO) Policy.
If a complaint is not within the jurisdiction of the Civil Rights Policy, the Civil Rights Officer will notify the complainant.
Definitions
Complainant
An individual(s) or other interested parties filing a civil rights complaint under this Policy. The complainant may include an individual(s) or other interested parties that:
- May or may not be directly injured.
- May believe they are or will be injured.
- May believe that an injury is about to occur or has occurred to others.
Discrimination
Engaging in prohibited discriminatory practices to treat unfavorably or deny fair and equal access to a CARB program or activity based on a protected class without legal justification. Discriminatory practices can include action or inaction. Examples of discriminatory practices can include:
- Denying a person the opportunity or right to apply for, receive the benefits of, or participate in a program or activity.
- Affording a person the opportunity or right to apply for, receive the benefits of, or participate in a program or activity that is not full and equal to the benefits of the program or activity afforded to others.
- Providing a program or activity to a person that is not as effective in affording a full and equal opportunity to obtain the same result, to gain the same benefit, or to reach the same level of achievement as that provided to others. In some situations, identical treatment may be discriminatory.
- Providing different or separate programs or activities to a person, or to any class of persons, than is provided to others, or providing programs or activities at a different time, unless such action is clearly necessary to provide such persons with full and equal access to as truly effective a program or activity as that provided to others.
- Aiding or perpetuating discrimination against a person by providing or transferring state support to a covered entity that discriminates in conduct, operation, or administration of any program or activity.
- Excluding a person from participation as a member of a planning or advisory board. Under this requirement, it is a discriminatory practice for a covered entity to fail to make reasonable efforts to achieve a representative board. However, such requirement is not deemed to impose adherence to a quota system.
- Limiting a person in the exercise or enjoyment of any right, privilege, advantage, or opportunity enjoyed by others participating in or receiving any aid, benefit, or service resulting from a program or activity.
- Denying a person the opportunity to participate in programs or activities that are not separate or different, despite the existence of permissibly separate or different programs or activities.
- Utilizing criteria or methods of administration that:
- Subject a person to discrimination on the basis of membership in, perception of membership in, or association with someone in a protected class;
- Defeat or substantially impair the accomplishment of the objectives of the covered entity’s program or activity with respect to membership in a protected class. The objectives of a program or activity shall include its overall mission or purpose as reflected in sources, such as relevant statutes, legislative intent and history, and regulations;
- Create, increase, reinforce, or perpetuate discrimination or segregation by another covered entity based on membership in a protected class; or
- Create, increase, reinforce, or perpetuate discrimination or segregation based on membership in a protected class.
- Subject a person to discrimination on the basis of membership in, perception of membership in, or association with someone in a protected class;
- Making or allowing selections or closures of sites or locations of facilities, or making, issuing, or denying permits for programs, services, activities, or facilities that:
- Exclude from, deny the benefits of, or otherwise subject persons to discrimination under any program or activity;
- Defeat or substantially impair the accomplishment of the objectives of the program or activity with respect to membership in a protected class; or
- Interfere with admittance to or enjoyment of public facilities or the rights of an individual with a disability under any program or activity.
- Exclude from, deny the benefits of, or otherwise subject persons to discrimination under any program or activity;
Prima Facie Complaint
Complaint allegations that, if assumed to be true, would be evidence of discrimination.
Protected Class
Refers to a basis on which individuals are entitled to protections against discrimination and denial of full and equal access to CARB programs and activities. Protected classes (or bases) include: age, ancestry, citizenship, color, disability (mental or physical), ethnicity, gender expression, gender identity, gender/sex, genetic information, marital status, medical condition, military/veteran status, national origin, political affiliation, race, religion, religious creed, religious dress and groom, sexual orientation, and any other status protected by state or federal law. An individual may be a member of multiple protected categories and file a complaint based on intersectional discrimination.
Respondent
The individual(s), programs, activities, or entities who the complainant alleges engaged in violations of this Policy.
Responsibilities
CARB or Other Entitles or People Affiliated with CARB
CARB employees, contractors, subcontractors, grantees, subgrantees, recipients, and vendorsare responsible for actions within their control to implement CARB programs and activities consistent with this Policy. CARB staff and management are required to provide information about programs and activities upon request by the Civil Rights Office, when relevant to this Policy. CARB contractors, subcontractors, grantees, subrecipients, and vendors are required to comply with this Policy as specified in their respective agreements with CARB and are required to provide information about their state-funded activities in response to relevant Civil Rights Office requests.
CARB’s Executive Officer
CARB’s Executive Officer holds final authority and responsibility for ensuring compliance with this Policy. Complaints involving the Executive Officer may be filed and will be responded to by the Civil Rights Officer consistent with this Policy.
CARB’s Civil Rights Officer
CARB’s Civil Rights Officer,who reports to the Executive Officer, oversees implementation of this Policy within CARB, including to work with all appropriate staff and managers. The Civil Rights Officer coordinates compliance efforts, receives inquiries concerning civil rights requirements, and ensures CARB is complying with state and federal reporting and record retention requirements. The Civil Rights Officer will implement this Policy impartially and take all reasonable actions to avoid actual or perceived bias or conflicts of interest, including but not limited to, seeking investigatory support from outside parties.
Complaint Procedure
A Civil Rights complaint may be filed against CARB or other people or entities affiliated with CARB, including contractors, subcontractors, grantees, subgrantees, recipients, and vendors that CARB utilizes to provide benefits and services to members of the public.
1. Timeline for Filing a Complaint
The complainant must file their complaint within three years of the alleged discrimination, or within three years of when the complainant, based on reasonable due diligence, first obtained knowledge of the alleged discrimination.
CARB encourages complainants to consult with an attorney to ensure any statutory time constraints necessary to pursue any legal remedies available to the complainant outside of CARB’s process for addressing complaints of discrimination are met.
2. Information Needed in the Complaint
The complainant must provide information to the Civil Rights Office about their complaint for the Civil Rights Office to review to determine the appropriate response.
The complainant can provide this information to the Civil Rights Office through a phone call, in an email to [email protected], or through filling out a Civil Rights Complaint Form and submitting it to [email protected]. Please contact [email protected] or contact (916) 323-7053, or visit CARB’s website on Civil Rights.
The information needed to make a complaint is the following:
- The complainant’s current contact information or the contact information of their authorized representative, including telephone number, email address, and mailing address. The complainant must inform CARB’s Civil Rights Officer of any changes to this information during CARB’s review process through resolution of the complaint with CARB. A complaint may be made anonymously; however, the Civil Rights Office might not be able to sufficiently review the complaint or provide relevant notices regarding the complaint without contact information for the complainant.
- A detailed description of the alleged act(s) the complainant believes is discriminatory.
- The protected class of the person, group, or people subjected to the alleged discrimination or whether the allegation is retaliation.
- The identity of the CARB staff person or program or activity that is alleged to have engaged in discrimination, and the contact information of the individual or representative of the program or activity if available.
CARB’s Civil Rights Officer, or a person directed by the Civil Rights Officer, may request additional information to determine the appropriate response.
3. Complaint Review and Potential Investigation by the Civil Rights Office
The Civil Rights Office will review the complaint and relevant evidence to determine whether an allegation of discrimination under the Civil Rights Policy’s jurisdiction has been described within 90 days of receiving the complaint.
The Civil Rights Office will review the evidence provided by the complainant, which can include:
- Admissions, or expressions of bias against members of a protected class;
- Evidence showing purpose or intent to discriminate;
- Circumstantial evidence (i.e., information concerning the disproportionate or adverse effect of a practice on a protected class);
- Statistical data;
- Evidence of disparate impact discrimination (i.e., group of individuals or other members of a protected class receiving better or more attractive benefits, or benefits were reduced to certain members of a protected class);
- Conditions to receiving benefits of a program that disproportionately exclude certain individuals in a protected class; or
- Objectives of a program or activity substantially impair members of a protected class.
4. Civil Rights Office Review Standards
The Civil Rights Office will review whether the complaint shows the discrimination is occurring to the aggrieved individuals or groups by showing the following prima facie elements:
- The persons or group belong to a protected class;
- The persons or group were subject to adverse action; and
- Either proof of intentional discrimination, or for unintended discrimination, a causal connection or link existing between the individual’s or individuals’ protected class and the adverse action.
Where the complaint allegations do not meet prima facie elements (i.e., if assumed to be true, would not be discrimination), the Civil Rights Office will inform the complainant within 90 days, in writing that their complaint has not met the prima facie standard and will not be further investigated.
Where the complaint allegations do not meet the prima facie standard but should have further review by another appropriate CARB office to consider other appropriate responses, the Civil Rights Officer will forward the complaint to the appropriate contact. The Civil Rights Officer will inform the complainant within 90 days, either verbally or in writing if their matter is directed to another CARB office.
Where the complainant allegations meet prima facie elements, the Civil Rights Officer, or a person directed by the Civil Rights Officer, will inform the complainant that the complaint has been accepted for investigation within 90 days of receiving the complaint. The Civil Rights Officer, or person directed by the Civil Rights Officer, will conduct a prompt, neutral, and thorough investigation into the allegations. CARB does not waive any statute of limitations that may apply as CARB works with the complainant to resolve the complaint.
5. Civil Rights Office Review Procedures
When a complaint is accepted for investigation, the Civil Rights Office will take the following investigation steps:
- Notify the complainant the complaint has been accepted and will be investigated if the complainant submitted contact information with the complaint.
- If a complaint regarding an individual CARB employee, or individual or organizational entity contractor, subcontractor, grantee, subgrantees, recipient, and vendor is submitted, CARB will notify the respondent alleged to have engaged in discrimination or retaliation.
- Interview relevant internal and external witnesses and request and collect relevant documents and evidence.
- Review the facts and evidence collected, make factual findings, and reach a determination on the merits of whether the findings show a Policy violation based on a preponderance of the evidence. This means determining that factual evidence shows it is more likely than not true that a Policy violation occurred.
- Documenting the investigation in an internal report and preparing a summary report for the public.
- Notify the complainant and respondent in writing when CARB has reached a determination on the merits of the discrimination complaint if the complainant submitted contact information with the complaint.
For a complaint about a CARB program or activity, if the Civil Rights Officer determines based on a preponderance of the evidence that there was a violation of this Policy, it will take appropriate remedial action consistent with the law.
6. Notification of Alleged Violations
When a complaint is filed against a contractor, subcontractor, grantee, subgrantee, recipient, or vendor, if the Civil Rights Officer determines there is reasonable cause to believe that the entity has violated the statutes or regulations cited in California Government Code Section 11135, the Civil Rights Officer will notify the contractor, subcontractor, grantee, subgrantee, recipient, and vendor of such violation and submit a complaint detailing the alleged violations to the California Civil Rights Department for investigation and determination.
This complaint procedure is not intended as a prerequisite to seeking judicial or other relief, nor is it intended to foreclose a complainant from seeking judicial or other relief.
Confidentiality
CARB strives to protect the confidentiality of the complainant and all individuals involved in the civil rights complaint process to the fullest extent permitted by law. However, due to the nature of this process, absolute confidentiality cannot be guaranteed. The Civil Rights Officer may disclose information as necessary to resolve a complaint and to comply with CARB’s transparency principles and public records laws. Personally identifiable Information, such as disability, medical condition, or genetic information, will be kept confidential consistent with state law. If a remedial action results in employee discipline, the Civil Rights Officer may share information obtained during the complaint process with appropriate CARB personnel and external parties, including the State Personnel Board.
Retaliation Prohibited
CARB will not tolerate retaliation against a complainant or a participant in the complaint process. Anyone who believes that they have been subject to retaliation in violation of this Policy may file a complaint of retaliation with CARB’s Civil Rights Officer following the procedures outlined in this Policy.
Complaint Form
The Civil Rights Policy Complaint Form is available on this website Civil Rights Office.
Alternate Formats
If you need this document in an alternate format (i.e. Braille, large print) or another language, please contact CARB’s Civil Rights Officer at (916) 323-7053 or [email protected]. TTY/TDD/Speech to Speech users may dial 711 for the California Relay Service.
Filing of Complaints with Other Jurisdictions
Individuals may also choose to file a civil discrimination complaint in state or federal court. CARB encourages individuals to seek legal counsel to understand their rights, options, and requirements for pursuing a civil action.
An individual may also file formal administrative complaints of discrimination against CARB before, during, or after filing a complaint with CARB, with the agencies listed below. The California Civil Rights Department is the state agency charged with enforcing California’s civil rights laws, including California Government Code Section 11135, which prohibits state agencies from discriminating in state-funded programs. A complainant does not need to file a complaint with CARB before filing a complaint with the California Civil Rights Department. The U.S. Department of Justice is charged with enforcing Title VI, Civil Rights Act of 1964 for all recipients of federal funding. The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (U.S. EPA) is the federal agency charged with enforcing Title VI, Civil Rights Act of 1964 for recipients of U.S. EPA federal funding.
These agencies have specific time limits for filing complaints. Individuals who wish to pursue filing with these agencies should contact them directly to obtain further information about their processes and time limits.
1. California Civil Rights Department
(formerly Fair Employment and Housing (DFEH))
2218 Kausen Drive, Suite 100
Elk Grove, California 95758
(800) 884-1684 or (916) 478-7251 or TTY at (800) 700-2320
https://calcivilrights.ca.gov/
2. U.S. Department of Justice
Civil Rights Division
950 Pennsylvania Avenue, NW
Washington, D.C. 20530-0001
(202) 514-3847 or (855) 856-1247 (toll free) or TTY at (202) 514-0716
https://civilrights.justice.gov/
3. U.S. Environmental Protection Agency
Office of Civil Rights
Mail code 2310A
1200 Pennsylvania Avenue, NW
Washington, D.C. 20460
(202) 564-3316 or (202) 565-0196 (fax)
[email protected]
Legal References
Federal
- Title VI, Civil Rights Act of 1964, 42 U.S.C. § 2000d-2000d-7;
- Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act of 1973, 29 U.S.C. § 794-794a;
- Age Discrimination Act of 1975, 42 U.S.C. §§ 6101-6107;
- Sec. 13 of the Federal Water Pollution Control Act Amendments of 1972, 33 U.S.C. § 1251, 1281 (Clean Water Act);
- 40 C.F.R. Part 7 (§§ 7.10-7.180);
- Title IX of the Education Amendments of 1972 (20 U.S.C. § 1681-1688); and
- 40 C.F.R. Part 5 (§§ 5.100-5.605).